V.League's 18-Club Puzzle: When Quantity Leaves Quality Behind
V.League 1 dự kiến mở rộng từ 14 lên 16-18 đội trước năm 2027, nhưng nền tảng tài chính và quản trị yếu kém đang đặt ra câu hỏi lớn về chất lượng. Thành công không đến từ số lượng đội bóng mà từ khả năng vận hành bền vững. - Quảng Nam rút lui dù trụ hạng vì thiếu ngân sách năm 2026. - Bầu Đức chi 2.000 tỷ đồng cho HAGL trong 20 năm, đội vẫn đi xuống. - Hai CLB bị xử phạt giấy phép năm 2023 và hai CLB cấp phép có điều kiện năm 2026. - Nhật Bản có 20 CLB, Hàn Quốc 12, Thái Lan 16, Indonesia 18, cho thấy số đội không quyết định chất lượng. - Mô hình tài chính hiện tại phụ thuộc ngân sách địa phương và mạnh thường quân, thiếu nguồn thu bền vững. Nguồn: Phân tích chuyên sâu V.League, tháng 6/2026 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Hỏi: Mở rộng V.League có giúp đội tuyển quốc gia mạnh hơn? Đáp: Thêm bốn CLB tạo khoảng 100-120 suất và 500-700 phút thi đấu chính thức mỗi vòng cho cầu thủ trẻ, nhưng chất lượng sẽ pha loãng ở vị trí khan hiếm. Hỏi: Vì sao Quảng Nam rút lui dù trụ hạng? Đáp: Quảng Nam không đủ ngân sách vận hành ở V.League 1, cho thấy vấn đề thanh khoản nghiêm trọng của các CLB. Hỏi: Giải pháp thay thế mở rộng là gì? Đáp: Áp dụng thể thức chia nhóm giúp tăng số trận mà không cần tăng số CLB, như Hàn Quốc và Nhật Bản.
Every summer has a god, and every god has a price. For V.League, the god of the past season was not a foreign striker who scored relentlessly, nor a contract that shook the transfer market. It was a club that had just survived relegation. Quang Nam, after completing its mission, withdrew from the league due to budget shortfalls. The club did not leave because it lost matches; it left because it could no longer afford to win. Around the same period, Dong A Thanh Hoa nearly collapsed entirely, saved at the last moment by a local government administrative intervention.
While the patient was leaving the emergency room, the talk turned to expanding the room itself. The plan to grow V.League 1 from 14 to 16 clubs, or even 18 clubs before 2027, has become the central topic in discussions about Vietnamese football's future. It is an ambition worth acknowledging, but also one that needs to be examined with colder eyes.
Looking around the region, people like to count clubs. Thailand has 16 in its top tier. Malaysia has 12. Indonesia has 18. Japan has 20. South Korea has 12. With 14 clubs, V.League sits at the lower end of the average, and the desire to expand is often justified by looking at neighbors. But numbers are just numbers. The health of a league is not measured by how many clubs take part, but by how each club manages to survive.
In Vietnam, survival has been consistently fragile. Three names regularly appear in the worry zone: Thanh Hoa, SLNA and Hai Phong - clubs that are difficult to run without local government budgets. Their existence resembles a contract that expires every season: funded this year, they must ask again next year, and if the flow of public money dries up, there is no reason left to exist. Quang Nam's withdrawal is the clearest proof. A club that had just avoided relegation still chose to walk away, because behind the results on the pitch there was no financial cushion thick enough to keep it there.
Bau Duc, who supported HAGL for twenty years, spent around 2,000 billion VND - a sum equivalent to several tens of millions of dollars per year. Yet HAGL, with the country's most famous academy, still experienced a decade of decline. Cong Phuong, Tuan Anh and the generations once expected to change the landscape gradually left. The enormous investment did not produce a championship machine; it only produced a surviving club. HAGL is the biggest lesson: money was not missing, but the model was. A single patron, no matter how generous, cannot replace governance, sustainable revenue and long-term strategy.
Over two decades of following Vietnamese football from small stands to international stadiums, I have noticed that reforms here usually begin with excitement and end with waiting. People wait for a boost from scale, while the disease sits in the root.
Look at the arithmetic of expansion. A 14-club league with a double round-robin has 26 rounds. Sixteen clubs have 30 rounds. Eighteen clubs have 34 rounds. Each new club brings flights, stops, rescheduled matches and negotiations. For football lovers, more matches is good news, but the quality of each match is something a fixture list cannot measure.
Dilution is not evenly distributed across positions. When a league expands, good players are not created out of thin air; they are spread over a wider area. In the positions where Vietnam is already scarce - quality goalkeepers, centre-backs who read the game, creative midfielders - dilution will be most visible. Matches with thinning technical quality tend to become physical, short on ideas and dependent on luck. That damages the very thing expansion promises: an attractive playground.
Financially, the calculation is even harsher. Within the current 14 clubs, signals from the licensing rounds suggest a significant share fail to meet standards: two clubs were penalised for licensing in 2026, and two clubs received conditional licences in 2026. Around 10 to 15 percent of current clubs are not fully compliant. Adding four clubs from the First Division, where infrastructure and budgets are weaker, would very likely bring two or three more non-compliant clubs. At that point, the licensing system faces a dilemma: it either becomes a law nobody enforces, or a tool for removing clubs by administrative decision. Both outcomes damage the league's integrity.
What makes every calculation difficult is the absence of three revenue legs. Sustainable leagues stand on ticket sales, broadcast rights and sponsorship. V.League has all three, yet all three are too weak to measure. A club leaning on local budget resembles a tree rooted in rock, surviving on seasonal rain.
Licensing, at present, is the last quality-control mechanism V.League has. When it fails, there is nothing behind it. The sequence of events over five years - one withdrawal, one near-collapse, two penalties, two conditional licences - is a negative trend with no corrective phase. Who can say that by 2027 the situation will improve, when the existing clubs have not yet learned to stand on their own?
There is an argument often repeated: more clubs, more talent. But looking at East Asia, we see that having more clubs does not automatically mean more talent. Japan has 20 clubs, South Korea only 12, yet the K-League still sustains 38 matches per season through a split format. Thailand has 16 clubs but plays only 30 rounds. Indonesia has 18 clubs, yet nobody rushes to conclude Indonesian football is ahead of Thailand simply because of the headcount. The correlation between club numbers and league level is weak, or absent.
What this story misses is format design. If the real desire is more matches, a league with 12 or 14 clubs and a two-stage split format can easily produce 38 matches per season - more than V.League's current 30 rounds - without investing in four new machines. Compared with carrying four extra clubs, this option is cheaper, less risky and more stable. But it rarely reaches the discussion table, because talking about format is not as thrilling as talking about admitting new clubs.
There is also an old question so old that many forget it has never been answered: the question of fairness. In 2026, disputes linked to multi-club ownership began to surface. Thirteen years later, the problem remains, only in different forms. Who will protect the league's fairness when one person holds both economic power and football influence? This is not a question about referees; it is about the structure of power. One can adjust fixtures and regulations, but if power remains in the hands of those who own clubs, every final decision will lean in their favour.
However, I want to stand with those who still believe in the expansion path, even while seeing the risks clearly. Because it cannot be denied that four new clubs mean hundreds of starting slots for young players - the thing Vietnamese football craves more than anything. A wider league will push academies to work harder, and young talents will have a space to make mistakes without paying with their entire careers. Done properly, expansion could become a boost for infrastructure and football culture in provinces that have never had a professional club.
But “done properly” is a very large condition. In Vietnamese football, people often talk about scale before talking about institutions. They may agree to expand to 18 clubs, but nobody clarifies who will pay for stadiums, youth teams, travel costs and licensing compliance. Clubs dependent on local budgets will not automatically escape hardship when the club count rises; conversely, limited public money will have to be divided among more clubs.
People call it football, but I call it a manuscript that is always being rewritten. The V.League 2027 manuscript is half-written, with expansion numbers and promises of a bigger league. But a society can paint ambitions on paper, while a football league cannot pretend to be sustainable. We love a club the way we love a poem - not for its meaning, but for its rhythm. Yet the rhythm of a league comes from clubs that know how to stand, not from the number of teams in the table. Before thinking about expansion, let the current 14 clubs prove they can survive three consecutive seasons. If they cannot, adding four more clubs will not create a bigger manuscript; it will only blur the pages further. A league does not die from lacking clubs. It dies when the clubs that are present stop being themselves.



Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
Manchester United Before the Atletico Madrid Test: When the Flanks Become the Killing Zone2026-10-14
U23 Vietnam vs U23 Philippines: 27 Shots, 1 Goal and a Mission That Cannot Wait2026-09-19
The Leo Jr Shirt at Hang Day: How a Brazilian Striker Found Himself Again in the V.League2026-10-16
Madam Pang and Brunei: When the International Calendar Filled King's Cup's Empty Seat2026-10-17
Undisclosed Contracts and the 22 Percent Wage-Bill Gap in V.League 12026-10-16
The Cong Viettel Lose to Persib Bandung: A Self-Inflicted Defeat and Its Far-Reaching Consequences2026-10-15
Bài đề xuất
Vietnam U20 and the 'Must-Win' Equation: When Expectations Become a Burden2026-09-04
VAR in the V.League: When Technology Exposes How We Define Error2026-10-10
V-League 2026-2027 Kicks Off: Suspensions Cast a Shadow Over Opening Day2026-09-04
V.League Does Not Produce Strikers: The Structure Behind Vietnam's 2026 ASEAN Championship Title2026-09-22
Da Nang's 1-5 Defeat: Stop Calling It Cruelty, Call It What It Is2026-10-18
Vietnam U17 at the 2026 World Cup: Schedule, Paperwork and the Real Gap in Group G2026-09-11
